Nexus 5X or Nexus 6P: Which one should you buy?

It's the toughest dilemma Android fans have faced in ages, but we can help you choose one of Google's great new Nexus phones.

nexus6p or5x 2589
Credit: Florence Ion

Life is full of difficult decisions, and as Android fans we’re facing our most difficult decision yet: choosing which Nexus device to buy.

If you think I’m kidding, then you haven’t read our reviews of the Nexus 6P or Nexus 5X. These two smartphones are the full package, complete with the latest version of Android Marshmallow and powerful hardware to back it up. Their camera abilities are actually pretty decent this time around, too, and both phones feature lightning fast fingerprint scanners that rival Apple’s and Samsung’s. Not to mention that these are Google phones, so they’ll be the first to get every major Android software update. 

We've never had to make this choice before. Google has always released one new Nexus phone each year, but now, with two on offer, the question naturally arises: which is the best choice for me?

Before you go putting a Nexus device on your credit card, consider the following criteria to help you figure out which Nexus device to adopt in your life.

Big or small?

Do you have big hands? Small pockets? Do you mind if your phone is a bit heavy? These are all things to consider before choosing between the Nexus 6P and 5X, because both phones cater to slightly different smartphone users.

nexus6p or5x 2627 Florence Ion

The Nexus 5X is a light phone with a plastic build. It’s pretty easy to wield or put in your pocket. 

The Nexus 5X serves not only as fan service for those that loved the Nexus 5, but for those of you who’d rather wield a smaller, lighter device. It weighs only 136 grams—that’s the same weight as the original 3.5-inch iPhone—though it’s also made of plastic, which makes it feel a bit cheap. That doesn’t mean it isn’t solidly built, however, and in our testing it didn’t twist, bend, or flex. Its smaller size also ensures your thumb can easily reach the power and volume buttons, and it fits more easily into pants pockets and smaller purses. 

nexus6p or5x 2626 Florence Ion

If you like bigger, premium phones, you can’t go wrong with the Nexus 6P—though it might not fit in your jacket pocket.

The Nexus 6P is a much larger phone, though not as gargantuan and unwieldy as last year’s Nexus 6. Its 5.7-inch screen puts it into phablet territory. You should expect that it won’t easily fit into most pants pockets, though its larger size is better for multitasking and long-form reading. I can more easily read through an ebook or an article online than I can with the 5X, though one-handed usage is a bit more tricky. There have been too many times I’ve felt like I was going to drop the 6P because my fingers couldn’t grip it tightly enough.

nexus6p or5x 2604 Florence Ion

Women are pretty screwed in the “put your phones in your pocket” department, anyway, but at least the Nexus 5X doesn’t stick out as much.

The “P” in its name stand for “premium,” which perfectly sums up the 6P’s sleek and fashionable aluminum frame. This is definitely a phone you’ll want to cover up in a case if you’re hoping to avoid scratches on the exterior, however—my 6P is already starting to see some wear and tear after only two weeks. It’s also fairly heavy at about 178 grams, which makes it heavier than the Samsung Galaxy S6HTC One M9, and Nexus 5X.

How bright do you need your screen?

nexus6p or5x screencomparo Florence Ion

It’s tough to capture in a photograph, but the 6P’s display is ever-so-slightly brighter and more saturated than the 5X’s.

The Nexus 5X’s screen is a 5.2-inch 1080p LCD display, while the 6P’s is a 5.7-inch Quad HD AMOLED display—the same AMOLED display used in Samsung’s flagship devices this year. Both screens are crisp and clear and offer fantastic viewing angles, but there is a slight color difference between the two. The 5X’s colors are a bit subdued, while the 6P’s are more vibrant, with a twinge of over-saturation that’s typical of Samsung AMOLED displays. The 6P display is also brighter. We measured it to be around 150 nits brighter than the 5X, so you'll be able to read it more easily in bright sunlight.

How much storage do you need?

nexus6p or5x 2598 Florence Ion

The Nexus 5X is only available in 16GB or 32GB.

If you want the smaller phone, you’ll have to opt for less storage space, too. The Nexus 5X is only sold in 16GB and 32GB variants, while the Nexus 6P comes in 32GB, 64GB, and 128GB flavors. There’s no expansion slot on either device, which is why the Nexus 5X’s storage limitation is kind of a bummer. The 32GB version of the 5X is $430, which is a reasonable amount of space for the price. To compare, the Moto X Pure Edition is $20 more for 32GB, but includes an expansion slot. 

12 megapixels vs. 12 megapixels

nexus6p or5x camera

On the left is the Nexus 5X and on the right is the Nexus 6P. 

Both the Nexus 5X and Nexus 6P boast 12.3-megapixel rear-facing cameras with 1.55 micron pixels and f/2.0 aperture, it's the same sensor, but there are some software differences between the two, made possible by the different SoCs which power the phones.

burst cover gif action 322542951869778

Instant GIFs are fun.

The Nexus 6P offers a special burst mode that can turn a series of quickly-shot images into a ready-to-share animated GIF. It’s not a “must have” feature, but it’s nice to have handy if you like to have fun with your social media postings. The 6P also takes slow motion video at 120fps and 240fps, compared to the 5X’s single-speed slow motion option, which only shoots at 120fps.

The only other advantage the 6P has over the 5X is that it features always-on electronic image stabilization. It’s not optical image stabilization (OIS), which both devices lack, but it does help cut down on the shakiness when you’re shooting video.

nexus6p or5x selfie

The Nexus 5X is on the left, and the Nexus 6P is on the right.

The phones have different front-facing camera sensors. The Nexus 5X offers a 5-megapixel front-facing camera, while the Nexus 6P offers an 8-megapixel one. If you like higher-resolution selfies, then the 6P is a better choice. It’s also better at capturing the white balance in the room. Anyway, none of that is noticeable once you compress an image to post it to Instagram.

Processing power and battery life

The Nexus 6P and Nexus 5X run on two of the latest Qualcomm Snapdragon processors. The 5X runs in line with LG G4 and Moto X Pure Edition with its Snapdragon 808 processor and 2GB of RAM, while the 6P is more apt to compete in the top-of-the-line space with its Snapdragon 810 processor and 3GB of RAM. Both phones are generally quick and snappy, though the 5X did suffer from infrequent interface sluggishness.

nexus 5x 6p battery chart

The Nexus 6P lasts longer than the Nexus 5X, but it also has a bigger battery pack.

In terms of everyday performance, the two devices differ most significantly when it comes to battery life. The 5X features a 2700 mAh battery pack, which is quite beefy for a 5.2-inch device under $400. In our PCMark and Geekbench battery testing, the phone ran for 5 hours 43 minutes and 4 hours 53 minutes, respectively. Real world performance was much better, but when you compare that to the Nexus 6P’s 3450 mAh battery pack, which outlasted most other flagships in its price range, you might want to consider forking over the extra money for the bigger device. Android 6.0’s Doze mode certainly helps out with both devices, but that only kicks in when either device has been left untouched and unmoved for a while. 

Which one is right for you?

gb nexus chart

The Nexus 6P is a better deal than most other flagships on the market right now, including the Galaxy S6, which features a bloated, blue-hued version of Android. It costs $100-200 less than most high-end phones with comparable specs, features, and build quality. The Nexus 5X, on the other hand, has quite a bit competition in the sub-$400 market. It’s not necessarily the best phone in its class, but it will get its Android updates before other phones.

Before you hit the “buy” button in the Google Play store, consider which phone offers the most features in your favor. For instance, you want a smaller and lighter smartphone with a capable camera and decent battery life, the Nexus 5X is a great option. There are other comparable phones at its sub-$400 price, but none of them offer a pure Android, bloat-free experience that gets all Android updates right away. But if you’re aching for something a little more premium, with stereo speakers and a brighter Quad HD display, the Nexus 6P is worth the splurge. Overall, your decision will depend entirely on your own budget and preferences, but at least you have two stellar smartphones to choose between.

This story, "Nexus 5X or Nexus 6P: Which one should you buy?" was originally published by Greenbot.

Shop Tech Products at Amazon